|
"Los Angeles, ...the future home of the NFLs
32nd team."
--Paul Tagliabue, NFL Commissioner, standing in the Los Angeles
Coliseum, 1999
"No."
--Paul Tagliabue, when asked if an NFL team would play in the Coliseum,
2002
Welcome to Our Solution
Now is the time to bring the NFL back to its earlier position.
That is the goal of www.LAColiseum Stadium.com, to support the efforts
of the private and public sector to bring NFL football back to the
Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum.
The Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum is more than just a landmark or
an historical building designation. It is the home of millions of
memories over the past 75 years. It is ready to again become home
of an NFL team and their fans, and thus the home of many more wonderful
memories.
We at www.LAColiseumStadium.com are answering the call for creative
solutions to the L.A. Stadium issue, to attract an owner with a
plan that will satisfy both the team and the City without requiring
new tax dollars.
QUITE SIMPLY: WE DON'T WANT TO LOSE ANOTHER BID FOR AN NFL TEAM.
But as Bob Dylan sang, "The times, they are a changin'."
Even so, we can gain a team if we all work together to make it work.
We at www.LAColiseumStadium.com are 100% NFL Football fans. We
are totally independent of the Coliseum or any NFL team and any
of their organizations. However, as we want to work with both any
prospective team and the city, we invite them along with the citizens
of Los Angeles to join with us in working out a solution together
which will work to the benefit of all the people (local fans who
are the taxpayers) of Los Angeles, large and small businesses impacted
directly and indirectly by the presence of an NFL team, the Mayor,
the City Council, and the fans of Los Angeles worldwide. We are
available to consult to whoever wants us to take further the work
we have already completed.
Los Angeles is a special place. Game 7
of the Lakers Sacramento pulled a higher TV rating in L.A.
than this years Super Bowl. L.A. is a sports town. And no
sports town is complete without an NFL team. Who will forget the
outpouring of fans and cheering an chanting for the Three-Peat Champion
Lakers. We need more parades. We need more outlets for what J.A.
Adande reports City Councilman Mark Ridley-Thomas calls our "psychic
income", to help focus our "civic energy". And we
especially need one for an NFL team championship, a team in the
biggest and most exclusive club in sports. As City Councilman Ridley-Thomas
also said, "The larger a city is, the more it needs things
that helps them come together and be a city. Teams do that like
nothing else can." So lets stand up for city and its needs.
Planning issues are merely details. Together, we can deal with them.
The Memorial Coliseum is a special place.
It is the only stadium in the world to stage opening ceremonies
for two Summer Olympic games, 1932 and 1984. It played host to the
first ever Super Bowl. It is where, when it was home to the Dodgers
before their move to Chavez Ravine, where 93,000 fans illuminated
it with lit matches in a tribute to Roy Campanella, who had been
disabled in a car accident. The Coliseum has hosted a variety of
globally important events, including the 1988 Amnesty International
Tour, 1987 Papal mass (the first-ever papal visit to L.A.), and
the Billy Graham Crusade, which set an all-time attendance record
of 134,254.
Pro Sports Realities: The NFL is run by
bright, creative, highly savvy people. As a popular movie has stated,
its not how you play the game that counts, its how the game plays
you. The NFL is not run by fools. They wanted downtown and had every
right to position it as best. But now that it is gone, that leaves
the Coliseum. The Coliseum worked it out with the NFL before and
can do so again. Both need each other. Lets help them make a deal.
And we must not forget that the AEG folks had initially proposed
renovating the Coliseum. It is the right place. This is the right
time. This is also the conclusion of various leaders and leadership
groups in the city, including business and government leaders, and
including historical preservationists, the construction people,
the architects, and the Community Redevelopment Agency. So lets
stand up for this prime asset of our prime city. Planning issues
are merely details. Together, we can deal with them.
Thus, the reality is that both L.A. and the NFL need each other.
Who needs who the most is immaterial. What is material is that the
NFL will only have 32 teams for the foreseeable future. No more
expansion. That means the next team that will be moving will move
to L.A. Neither the NFL nor L.A., the 2nd largest market in the
United States, can continue to deny each other. Six teams mentioned
as candidates have been mentioned because they are having a hard
time making ends meet, as discussed below. The Memorial Coliseum,
with a mixed use real estate development/coliseum renovation plan,
can be profitable for both city and team.
The previous NFL teams, as well as the teams of the University
of Southern California and other college, and high school sports
teams, have always been part of the "common community ground"
that we have all shared together in Los Angeles. Most of us, when
we get together, begin with our common enjoyment of our teams, "breaking
the ice" with our takes on the Lakers and, oh thats right,
we dont have an NFL team, and other favorite teams, and then
we get on with the rest of our stories about other things we have
to do (work, family, projects, neighborhood, etc., whatever it may
be.
The Coliseum is home to one of the best football programs in the
nation, that of the University of Southern California. USC officials
count their campus among the 10 safest in the country.
NFL teams have NOT changed. Football has NOT changed. The enjoyment
and community camaraderie we get has NOT changed. The many common
community and business and personal benefits we get have NOT changed.
BUT! THE FINANCIAL ENVIRONMENT and related to that, the THE PHYSICAL
PLAYING FIELDS (now called "venues"), HAVE changed. For
a crisp analysis of the situation that best explains why cities
like Los Angeles have lost their teams, see the cover story on the
financial environment of the NFL and the crucial role played by
the stadiums, in the September 20, 1999 Forbes Magazine. We regret
the teams that left Los Angeles. That need not happen again. There
are lessons to be learned from mistakes made. We believe the Coliseum
Commission as well as representatives from the city, county, and
state, have a better understanding now of what needs to be done
to make it happen and will be able to exercise that understanding
positively for a public-private partnership that will work joyfully
for everyone.
If we want to keep the an NFL team, we have to adjust to the new
reality that professional sports is now both big business and big
entertainment.
BUT! It can still be a happy public-private partnership, just as
the ones that exist in many cities and which exists in many areas
of Los Angeles today. A workable model for the Coliseum can be developed
that will serve the city and a new team without having to raise
any new taxes.
We want to have a great season every year. Both national magazines
and our own local newspapers have underscored the fact that older
stadiums limit teams ability to do two critical things, FIRST,
run their business franchise profitably, and SECOND, field a competitive
team -- the kind of team our fans demand and we know a new team
would be committed to putting on the field. And in Los Angeles,
we have the quality of life many players would like to enjoy for
themselves and their families.
But the fact still remains that the business of professional football
is changing, and, as stated by the NFL and every team in the NFL,
teams need stadiums configured to enable them to keep pace with
the rest of the league. Without either a new stadium or additional
renovations to the Coliseum in order to facilitate additional revenue
sources other teams enjoy, a team cannot move here and survive.
Teams in the NFL are fortunate to play in a financially healthy
league with no labor problems, a league that works to ensure smaller-market
teams like San Diego have a chance to compete just as the larger
market teams in San Francisco, Oakland, and Los Angeles. And although
the bulk of shared revenues come from national broadcasting rights,
and each NFL team gets the same amount each year, additional revenues
are needed to keep pace with the escalating operating costs, which
can only be achieved with a stadium that enables new revenue, either
by renovating an existing stadium or building a new one. The shared
revenue scheme has not leveled the playing field. The larger markets
have built stadiums which can generate home town revenues for the
team. Prior Los Angeles teams were unable to make their case well.
And so they moved to where they could get a stadium that would enable
them to compete. To field any team and win, teams have to have stadiums
configured to enable that to happen. To return to the glory days
of the Rams of old, we need to replace or renovate the stadium so
a new team can play and compete.
Completing the Figueroa Corridor.
A renovated Coliseum will benefit downtown as much as the other
one would have. The Coliseum will be good for both L.A. and the
NFL. The L.A. Coliseum Stadium is more than about football and NFL.
It is also about a decades long attempt to complete the Figueroa
Corridor.
The AEG Group wanted to build a stadium at the other end of Figueroa.
As that plan has been withdrawn, we now focus on the Coliseum end
of Figueroa. Our goal is an NFL team. We dont care which end
of Figueroa it is on. But as one end is gone, lets now all pull
together to make it happen at the Coliseum end.
It is our Coliseum. We at www.ColiseumStadium.com believe that
by working together, we can develop a new financial model which
will satisfy the owners who need to make a profit, the taxpayers
who don't want to subsidize millionaires with new tax dollars, the
small businesses and others who profit from the games, and, of course
the fans for whom NFL teams have long been a cherished part of their
lives. We are inviting all the key players in the debate to work
hard to put their heads together to create a new financial paradigm
that works for Los Angeles, and which in turn works for the new
NFL team. As it does all of that, it will also work for the fans.
Located in the heart Los Angeles, the Memorial Coliseum is centrally
located and easily accessible. The Stadium can be reached by any
one of four freeways: the 805, 163, 15 and 8. And the San Diego
Trolley runs between the Stadium and Old Town. The stadium is for
the ages: it received the First Honor Award from the American Institute
of Architects. There are over 19,000 parking spaces, as well as
bus service to and from the Stadium, a Trolley that runs between
the Stadium and Old Town. It has seven different entrances into
the Stadium, that ensure that convenience is added to every visit.
Near the Harbor Freeway, there are six lots servicing the Coliseum
and Sports Arena on Menlo and Vermont Avenues, between Exposition
and Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd. and on MLK between Menlo and Figueroa.
A total of 20,000 parking spaces are available in the Exposition
Park area, at USC, the Shrine Auditorium and private lots within
walking distance of the complex. Any renovation will have to take
into consideration expanding parking.
REVENUE
Unfortunately, shared revenue is only one part of the stadium equation.
21st century profitability will be based on Non-shared revenues
which will come primarily from stadium sources such as concessions,
parking, suites, club seats, advertising and any other activities
which a team can develop and use to generate revenue. In 2002, these
revenues will vary greatly from team to team. To give you an idea,
we will compare the team that has been the two leading candidate
to make the move, The Minnesota Vikings and the San Diego Chargers,
because their cities, it is said, are unable to work to resolve
their stadium issue. The Vikings and the Chargers rank near the
bottom of the league. The Vikings are openly in the process of seeking
another city where it can obtain a stadium.
The San Diego Chargers are a privately owned team and so specific
information is not available. However, we can provide approximate
numbers for the Chargers and specific numbers for the Vikings:
RANKINGS
The salary cap helps teams like the Vikings and Chargers compete
for star players by putting a ceiling on the total amount teams
can pay players. But the salary cap is tied to the average NFL team
revenue and it will rise as the average team revenue rises. Without
a new or renovated stadium configured for new revenue sources, these
teams will fall further below average and will be faced with a tough
choice: pay up to the salary cap and lose money, or pay below the
cap and lose favorite, star players and, thus, winning seasons.
The following is information for, again, the Vikings and the Chargers,
who are each in a similar position.
|
Projected Rankings 1999 Source:
NFL CFO's office
|
|
|
Vikings
|
Chargers
|
Top Quartile Variance
|
|
Net Gate Receipts
|
25th
|
??
|
27.2%
|
|
Concessions
|
26th
|
??
|
90.2%
|
|
Suites
|
27th
|
??
|
75.2%
|
|
Parking
|
31st
|
??
|
100%
|
|
Club Seats/Stadium Club
|
31st
|
??
|
100%
|
|
Advertising
|
31st
|
??
|
100%
|
|
Total Revenue
|
30th
|
??
|
27.2%
|
A rank position like this seriously limits these teams to revenue
opportunities. They rank near the bottom among all NFL teams when
it comes to important stadium revenue sources like concessions,
parking, suites, club seats and advertising.
Because of shortfalls in every stadium revenue category, These
teams are projected to continue to rank low in the NFL in total
revenue for 2002. This will not improve without a new or renovated
stadium.
We also want a facility that better serves fans. More people than
ever are looking for a way to attend an NFL game. A Coliseum renovation
will offer better accommodations -- more restrooms, more concession
areas, wider concourses -- so fans no longer have to choose at half-time
between the restroom and a snack.
The following chart clearly shows the direction of the NFL with
regard to the importance of new stadium construction. This is why
teams not making it want to come to L.A. They are a necessary component
of being in business with the NFL.
|
STADIUM PROGRESS REPORT
|
|
Stadium/City
|
Team
|
Completion Year
|
|
Georgia Dome
|
Atlanta Falcons
|
1992
|
|
ALLTEL Stadium
|
Jacksonville Jaguars
|
1995
|
|
Trans World Dome
|
St. Louis Rams
|
1995
|
|
Network Associates Coliseum*
|
Oakland Raiders
|
1996
|
|
Ericsson Stadium
|
Carolina Panthers
|
1996
|
|
Louisiana Stadium
|
New Orleans Saints
|
1996
|
|
Qualcomm Stadium*
|
San Diego Chargers
|
1997
|
| Did not provide desired revenue
increases. |
|
Washington Redskins Stadium
|
Washington Redskins
|
1997
|
|
PSINet Stadium
|
Baltimore Ravens
|
1998
|
|
Giants Stadium*
|
New York Giants/Jets
|
1998
|
|
Raymond James Stadium
|
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
|
1998
|
|
Ralph Wilson Stadium*
|
Buffalo Bills
|
1999
|
|
Cleveland Browns Stadium
|
Cleveland Browns
|
1999
|
|
Adelphia Coliseum
|
Tennessee Titans
|
1999
|
|
RCA Dome*
|
Indianapolis Colts
|
1999
|
|
Paul Brown Stadium
|
Cincinnati Bengals
|
2000
|
|
Denver
|
Denver Broncos
|
2001
|
|
Foxboro
|
New England Patriots
|
2001
|
|
Pittsburgh
|
Pittsburgh Steelers
|
2001
|
|
Seattle
|
Seattle Seahawks
|
2002
|
|
Detroit
|
Detroit Lions
|
2002
|
|
Philadelphia
|
Philadelphia Eagles
|
2004
|
|
San Francisco
|
San Francisco 49ers
|
No Plans
|
|
Minnesota
|
Minnesota Vikings
|
No Plans
|
|
Number one candidate for relocation
|
|
*Renovations
|
CONCLUSION
We believe that there are enough examples out there to provide
Los Angeles with a model which will work for all concerned, from
the taxpayers, that is all citizens, to the legislators trying to
develop a public-private partnership that will satisfy all, to the
owners who will need to show a profit, to the coaches who need to
develop a competitive team, to the players on the field striving
to win a Super Bowl, and to the fans in the stands and watching
on TV and listening to the radio.
As fans, we're thinking football. We have also geared up for an
exciting 2002 season. At the same time, we would like to begin a
conversation about resolving the football stadium issue for Los
Angeles. We believe there is a stadium solution that will benefit
not only the team, but also fans and the City of Los Angeles. We
are committed, cooperatively to "Creating a solution to continue
a tradition."
We invite you to submit your suggestions. We will turn over every
suggestion we get to the Coliseum and to the mayor's office. We
will also continue to develop our own research, with the goal to
come up with a means and mechanism to achieve a win-win "conflict
resolution" for all sides concerned.
|